There are some very good points made here that people should be paying attention to.
However, they miss the mark on masks. What little they do address on the subject falls far short and they clearly do not understand the subject matter well at all. Those arguments made are both weak ridiculous. They hold no water.
They should stand on the ground they know which is the politics side. Some very intriguing and better detailed points there. Attacking OSHA and their position is similar to the fear tactics being employed by MSM and the far left. Exactly what they are pointing out as issues. And well so. However credibility starts to become lost when they sink to their level. The high road should be taken. In the short, it feels unfair but as information spreads and people better understand issues, this avenue becomes far superior than the alternative.
Masks work
Respirators work
Cloth masks? Maybe they help? It’s a precaution and no one can definitely say either way yet. Use is based on precautionary principle. There are issues surrounding use of such that certainly can be argued. Contamination potential and subsequent infection to be clear. However, probably lower risk when dealing with casual interactions within a public setting.
The CO2 angle is nonsense and has little application here. Comparing it to environmental issues and personal health as they did is silly and non relatable. Again, they need to take the high road rather than using buzz words employing fear mongering. I understand why they do.... but that doesn’t make it right.... or better.
I’ve posted the studies here that speak to CO2 rebreathing being a non-issue for respirators where there is a seal to the face and mask microclimate. Also the psychological effects of mask microclimate. Respirators do increase CO2 retention yes. But not to anywhere remotely near dangerous levels. As such, a cloth mask that does not seal of filter as efficiently should not create a worse condition.
Workers have wore respirators for years. And for extended periods of time. Their use has been extended and reuse has been accepted in some working environments. It is a new concept in healthcare.... and from an ICC standpoint a bit of a nightmare.... but required because of availability. Availability is of lesser concern these days as production has increased.
Lastly, no one will standby respirator or even mask use for those with cardiopulmonary issues. The CSA and ANSI standards speak to this in great detail. Public health acknowledges this for use in the public as well. Again there is no information on cloth masks for this, however this is acknowledged in their use as well and public health units are following this so anyone with a health issue that may be affected in a negative way does not have to mask.
Can’t speak for the US though. Their approach may be different and no doubts varies state to state. The OSHA has no skin in the game for public protection and as such will take no position as it’s beyond their mandate and jurisdiction.
One thing is for certain here that i know too well. Organizations with any possible relation to these issues at hand are certainly not extending themselves to assist in the provision of direction. They are too afraid of making a mistake. So it’s not surprising to see little comment from something like the US OSHA.
The virus is real and it can be deadly.
The ways and means it was unleashed onto the world? I don’t know. As I’ve stated I believed the narrative being explained early. Now I’m not so sure there wasn’t something greater and perhaps sinister behind it.
Are individuals using this virus now for political gain? 110% they are. There’s many angles feeding into it. Politics are certainly involved and to say they are not is foolish.
But that can’t or at least shouldn’t take away from from the ways and means to protect or attempt to control spread. Do politics muddy that water too? Absolutely.
I have little to no expertise or even experience on the politics at hand here. But strictly from a health protection angle I do. Source control? Somewhat.... and from where I sit there is something to be gained I believe. But that’s only opinion, but an educated one.
So masks work. They aren’t a heath risk if you are healthy. At least the ones we know about. These cloth ones? Time will tell.
Is some or much of this about politics? Yes. But thats beyond my strengths to really provide information on. I will defer to you folks who are far more in tune with that side.