The adenosine blocking effects of caffeine as it's "only" wakefulness effect never rang true to me either, as there is a clear stimulatory and thermogenic effect.
A limitation of the way modern medicine tends to approach single molecules is 1 molecule 1 function, where in reality that is almost never the case (but is usually the best business model.)
This 1968 paper I think describes the underlying mechanism of action in a more comprehensive way that explains the observed effects.
https://sci-hub.se/10.1085/jgp.52.5.760
This paragraph, sums up
"Evidence is presented that caffeine does not act on the mitochondrial Ca uptake system and that
its effect cannot be attributed to the accumulation of adenosine 3', 5r-phosphate. Two distinct caffeine effects are described.
At high ATP concentrations caffeine decreases the coupling between ATP hydrolysis and Ca inflow. It either inhibits inflow without any inhibition of the rate of ATP hydrolysis, or it stimulates the ATPase activity without stimulating Ca inflow. These high ATP concentrations (much higher than needed for the saturation of the transport ATPase) greatly reduce the control of the turnover rate of the transport system by accumulated Ca
. At low ATP concentrations when the transport system is under maximal control by accumulated Ca, caffeine inhibits the ATPase activity without affecting the rate of Ca inflow."
Caffeine modulating ATP / ATPase effects on calcium channels makes a lot more sense to me.
This newer (2013) paper describes the same effect, but from a "higher" level as it discusses caffeine's effect on glucose homeostasis.
I believe
@Sorbate has or had experienced this effect.
Hypoglycemia makes zero sense from an adenosine blocking only point of view.