Write the page because I am interested in your perspective.
Bagua, I don't want to sound insensitive or judgemental but from personal experience and reading I find people who become obese state it isn't their fault. There are exception - high dose prednisone can make you hungry and make you gain weight. Remeron and Lyrica both increase your appetite and if you have no self control you will overeat. I have seen this first hand.
For high level athletes there is much more than just calories in and calories out and macros but in most cases that is the basis for people being obese. I don't know how many people I know who are obese and ask if there is a remedy (medication) they can take to help because they don't eat much. I have meals with them and their plates are full of massive amounts of carbohydrates, small portions of protein and then desert comes. Instead of passing on the desert, they have two. I never comment to these folks as it is their life but if they tracked what they ate vs. calories burnt off, it would be very obvious.
Further, many of these people won't exercise in an form - for the few who asked for help I suggested start small - walk around the block after meals and cut out pop and sugar drinks. I'm not a nutritionist but common sense is to make small changes and don't try to do it all at once or you will likely fail. Short exercises sessions to burn off calories - hell they might even enjoy it and find their joints don't hurt as much. Cut out some of the bad foods they know must be attributing to their weight but not all at once.
When people age, hormones change and it is harder to stay lean/easier to gain weight if you don't adjust your diet/exercise so if you don't want to be over weight, adjust your damn diet and find an exercise you can do even if it means low impact water exercises. I can understand some exercises may not be feasible when you are at a certain size, but there is something you can do - pools are great, work out at home to get use to movement, or walking.
When I was taking Lyrica for nerve pain for a few months, I woke up hungry and my desire to eat was increased but I didn't. I have been on Remeron (perioidcally) for sleep (low dose) but it makes you very hungry but I didn't go to the fridge and eat another meal when I know I don't need it. Am I special/perfect - not in the least/far from it and many people are the same but all it is willpower (exceptions below).
All that being said, I have empathy for people who use food for self-medication (comfort food) but not once a week or once a month - daily. They end up with sore joints, feel like shit, are overweight, and some get diabetes or serious diseases. Some medications may contribute as do genetics - absolutely but with some willpower you can stop overeating and start some form of exercise program that suits your life style. In other words - try something.
The best remedy for these scenarios, when it is a self-medication issue, is to get help from a professional and deal with the issue and if needed get medication for that issue or stick with therapy (or both).
Just like building muscle and getting in shape, it is a slow process and losing weight and becoming healthy for someone who is very unhealthy/very overweight is the same. Don't shock your body but take slow steps monthly to get there. It may take a long time to get there but unless you are disabled and can't exercise, there is something everyone can do. Walk with your dogs - pick things you enjoy that get you moving.
Most doctors are not blunt enough and they should be. My old doctor used to say to people who smoked, you should quit before you start coughing up pieces of your lungs. He was blunt but was saying it because he cared. There is a way to say it but the message should be clear - stop or your running the risk of serious illnesses or worse.
If doctors don't have the time to discuss nutrition, then they should be referring someone to a nutritionist. Ignoring it just means more stress on the health system down the road.
There are exceptions to every comment I make, hence not wanting to sound judgemental but the world is becoming obese, just look at the statistics. It costs more to eat better, we all know that. Crap food is cheaper - why the F is that? Anyone who knows me knows I have empathy and my comments do not apply to people who are disabled and can't exercise but sometimes you have to look in the mirror and take responsibility for the person looking back at you.
I am not a doctor or nutritionist - maybe there are people who are and they can educate me. I can't count the times someone I know who is put on a SSRI and gain 50 lbs. They state it is the medication - is it the medication or is it because the medication makes you hungry and feed the cravings?
In my limited experience with fasting - hunger pains go away. When I want to lose weight, I eat a different diet and potentially less meals. I assume it is the same for most people but maybe I am completely wrong.