ah ok. so if it was your average licensed unrestricted firearm, he wouldn’t have been charged with anything? i feel like they still would since it’s Canada after all.
Ya they likely would have charged him with something regardless... In Canada, the gun storage laws are so f'ing tight that courts/law will saw that you had enough time to call 911/leave etc before you had time to unlock and load your gun.. That's what we were told in our firearms course..
In Canada your non restricted firearms have to either be locked in a gun safe or the firearm must have a trigger lock on it.. and your ammo can't be "readily accessible".. whatever that means..
Basically the laws for storage make it so that if you actually get your gun and load it during a B and E and/or shoot something, the court/law will show try to show that you fully intended to shoot someone and were not simply acting in self defense..
Again, this is what we are taught in various gun courses I've taken.
Restricted (handguns) are quite a bit more intense.. They need a trigger lock.. then locked in a separate container ... Bascially trigger locked and locked in a gun safe.. Your ammo for handguns must be locked up seperately from the handgun.. theres also laws about where the keys can be stored for the trigger locks..
All that being said, I don't know many firearms owners where I live who don't have a gun handy... I've been on the phone with 911 with a shotgun in my hand at 1am and the 911 person knew it.. I've had RCMP come to my house for a call (made by me) where I bluntly told them I fired a shotgun into the ground.. I would never actively seek out to hurt someone, but man alive the crime where I live is insane.. plus we get predators.. I had a mother black bear and her 2 cubs in our front yard this fall in the middle of the day... My kids play outside all the time.
It's one thing to sit with a loaded gun inside your house when you can hear someone breaking into your car or garage.. It's another thing to leave your house with a loaded gun because someone is breaking into your car or garage.. leave your house with the gun when you don't have to will likely get you into trouble.. shoot someone whose broken into your house and is standing in your living room is likely a different story..
My wife has been told when I'm not home, don't hesitate for a second to shoot someone whose broken into our house.. of course call 911 first.. but I told her there is no friggin way a jury would find a 120 lbs female guilty of shit if she shot a male whose broken into our house when I'm not home.
I personally think your unintelligent if that gun you keep handy is a handgun.. You'll likely be banned from owning firearms if you get caught with a handgun during a B and E plus criminal record/jail/massive fines etc. And to be perfectly honest, handguns are only great defense guns if you are like 20 feet away.. They would not be my choice at all for self defense at home.. A short pump shotgun would be ideal.. I don't know many criminals that wouldn't stop in their tracks when they hear the slide of a pump shotgun load a round.
When I first started shooting handguns, one of my first thoughts was "holy fuck... I wouldn't be scared if somone was standing 40 yards from me shooting at me with a handgun"... to be honest, they are incredibly hard to hit a beachball target at 20 yards in broad daylight at the gun range without lots of practise.. I couldn't imagine trying to hit a beachball at 20 yards in the dark with my blood pumping and chaos all around me.. lol
I say take the shotgun away in this new hypothetical as it would appease the anti gun folk, meet in the middle type of deal. Treat it like putting down an animal that has consumed human flesh hahaha. Keep the homeowner’s record clean and allow them to continue as normal. They won’t want to have the conversation about how this was definitely traumatizing to the home owner as well, not just a bad guy with a gun!