Home invaders now charged with murder if the home owner kills them!

reading between the lines in the article I think it was a handgun... want to save yourself a huge headache if someone breaks in? Don't grab a handgun.. grab a shotgun.
ah ok. so if it was your average licensed unrestricted firearm, he wouldn’t have been charged with anything? i feel like they still would since it’s Canada after all.

I say take the shotgun away in this new hypothetical as it would appease the anti gun folk, meet in the middle type of deal. Treat it like putting down an animal that has consumed human flesh hahaha. Keep the homeowner’s record clean and allow them to continue as normal. They won’t want to have the conversation about how this was definitely traumatizing to the home owner as well, not just a bad guy with a gun!
 
Still remember like it was yesterday..... Cops knocked on buddy's door. He opened it and without the cops saying a thing yelled "I don't know anything. Get out of here and don't come back without a warrant". He took both hands on the door and slammed it so hard it shook the house and he deadbolted the door. The cops left LOL
 
ah ok. so if it was your average licensed unrestricted firearm, he wouldn’t have been charged with anything? i feel like they still would since it’s Canada after all.

Ya they likely would have charged him with something regardless... In Canada, the gun storage laws are so f'ing tight that courts/law will saw that you had enough time to call 911/leave etc before you had time to unlock and load your gun.. That's what we were told in our firearms course..

In Canada your non restricted firearms have to either be locked in a gun safe or the firearm must have a trigger lock on it.. and your ammo can't be "readily accessible".. whatever that means..

Basically the laws for storage make it so that if you actually get your gun and load it during a B and E and/or shoot something, the court/law will show try to show that you fully intended to shoot someone and were not simply acting in self defense..

Again, this is what we are taught in various gun courses I've taken.

Restricted (handguns) are quite a bit more intense.. They need a trigger lock.. then locked in a separate container ... Bascially trigger locked and locked in a gun safe.. Your ammo for handguns must be locked up seperately from the handgun.. theres also laws about where the keys can be stored for the trigger locks..


All that being said, I don't know many firearms owners where I live who don't have a gun handy... I've been on the phone with 911 with a shotgun in my hand at 1am and the 911 person knew it.. I've had RCMP come to my house for a call (made by me) where I bluntly told them I fired a shotgun into the ground.. I would never actively seek out to hurt someone, but man alive the crime where I live is insane.. plus we get predators.. I had a mother black bear and her 2 cubs in our front yard this fall in the middle of the day... My kids play outside all the time.

It's one thing to sit with a loaded gun inside your house when you can hear someone breaking into your car or garage.. It's another thing to leave your house with a loaded gun because someone is breaking into your car or garage.. leave your house with the gun when you don't have to will likely get you into trouble.. shoot someone whose broken into your house and is standing in your living room is likely a different story..

My wife has been told when I'm not home, don't hesitate for a second to shoot someone whose broken into our house.. of course call 911 first.. but I told her there is no friggin way a jury would find a 120 lbs female guilty of shit if she shot a male whose broken into our house when I'm not home.

I personally think your unintelligent if that gun you keep handy is a handgun.. You'll likely be banned from owning firearms if you get caught with a handgun during a B and E plus criminal record/jail/massive fines etc. And to be perfectly honest, handguns are only great defense guns if you are like 20 feet away.. They would not be my choice at all for self defense at home.. A short pump shotgun would be ideal.. I don't know many criminals that wouldn't stop in their tracks when they hear the slide of a pump shotgun load a round.

When I first started shooting handguns, one of my first thoughts was "holy fuck... I wouldn't be scared if somone was standing 40 yards from me shooting at me with a handgun"... to be honest, they are incredibly hard to hit a beachball target at 20 yards in broad daylight at the gun range without lots of practise.. I couldn't imagine trying to hit a beachball at 20 yards in the dark with my blood pumping and chaos all around me.. lol



I say take the shotgun away in this new hypothetical as it would appease the anti gun folk, meet in the middle type of deal. Treat it like putting down an animal that has consumed human flesh hahaha. Keep the homeowner’s record clean and allow them to continue as normal. They won’t want to have the conversation about how this was definitely traumatizing to the home owner as well, not just a bad guy with a gun!
 
off topic, but it pisses me off when I hear people say they don't hunt, they love animals.. This assumes that if you hunt, you don't love animals.. I've found this to be completely opposite when you get to know hunters.
Yeah, every hunter i know has a great love and respect for animals and the outdoors. Hunting your food is far more ethical than eating an animal that was raised for slaughter in factory-farm conditions.

Besides, shooting an animal is dealing them a kinder death than what they would otherwise face in nature. Prey animals don't reach a ripe old age then lay down and die peacefully. No, they get old and slow, and ultimately get eaten alive, asshole-first, by a pack of hungry wolves!
 
off topic, but it pisses me off when I hear people say they don't hunt, they love animals.. This assumes that if you hunt, you don't love animals.. I've found this to be completely opposite when you get to know hunters.

Yeah, every hunter i know has a great love and respect for animals and the outdoors. Hunting your food is far more ethical than eating an animal that was raised for slaughter in factory-farm conditions.

Besides, shooting an animal is dealing them a kinder death than what they would otherwise face in nature. Prey animals don't reach a ripe old age then lay down and die peacefully. No, they get old and slow, and ultimately get eaten alive, asshole-first, by a pack of hungry wolves!
do the people walking into grocery stores , with the mistreated garbage fed animals have more love for animals? They're just keeping the cycle going...
 
off topic, but it pisses me off when I hear people say they don't hunt, they love animals.. This assumes that if you hunt, you don't love animals.. I've found this to be completely opposite when you get to know hunters.
I think i just said it poorly. I dont like watching animals die. I've killed plenty in my life and feel no need putting myself through that for sport. I did say I would hunt moose and probably deer just because id love to fill my freezer with good healthy meat but I dont have any drive to hunt for passion. The same with farming I would have my own cattle but I cant detach myself from them enough to raise them and slaughter them. I may just be soft in this sense or have just been traumatized slightly from seeing animals die. Ive worked in a slaughterhouse before and seen some other pretty horrible things. I dont have anything against hunting and I also had a criminal record and fire arms prohibition for most of my life so hunters also never been an opinion for me. What pisses me off is these guys who just get hammered and go out blowing away anything that moves or these goofs you see killing animals for fun. I know some guys who if their dog breaks a leg rather then go to the vet they just put one in the back of its head and if you ask me these guys need a good beat down and something to humble their attitude towards life and the life of other creatures. Yes I understand and apreciate the argument that hunting will give the animal a quicker more humane death then in the wild.
 
off topic, but it pisses me off when I hear people say they don't hunt, they love animals.. This assumes that if you hunt, you don't love animals.. I've found this to be completely opposite when you get to know hunters.
I think i just said it poorly. I dont like watching animals die. I've killed plenty in my life and feel no need putting myself through that for sport. I did say I would hunt moose and probably deer just because id love to fill my freezer with good healthy meat but I dont have any drive to hunt for passion. The same with farming I would have my own cattle but I cant detach myself from them enough to raise them and slaughter them. I may just be soft in this sense or have just been traumatized slightly from seeing animals die. Ive worked in a slaughterhouse before and seen some other pretty horrible things. So much so that i have nightmares about slaughthouses so it must have effected me. I dont have anything against hunting and I also had a criminal record and fire arms prohibition for most of my life so hunters also never been an opinion for me. What pisses me off is these guys who just get hammered and go out blowing away anything that moves or these goofs you see killing animals for fun. I know some guys who if their dog breaks a leg rather then go to the vet they just put one in the back of its head and if you ask me these guys need a good beat down and something to humble their attitude towards life and the life of other creatures. Yes I understand and apreciate the argument that hunting will give the animal a quicker more humane death then in the wild.
 
I think i just said it poorly. I dont like watching animals die. I've killed plenty in my life and feel no need putting myself through that for sport. I did say I would hunt moose and probably deer just because id love to fill my freezer with good healthy meat but I dont have any drive to hunt for passion. The same with farming I would have my own cattle but I cant detach myself from them enough to raise them and slaughter them. I may just be soft in this sense or have just been traumatized slightly from seeing animals die. Ive worked in a slaughterhouse before and seen some other pretty horrible things. So much so that i have nightmares about slaughthouses so it must have effected me. I dont have anything against hunting and I also had a criminal record and fire arms prohibition for most of my life so hunters also never been an opinion for me. What pisses me off is these guys who just get hammered and go out blowing away anything that moves or these goofs you see killing animals for fun. I know some guys who if their dog breaks a leg rather then go to the vet they just put one in the back of its head and if you ask me these guys need a good beat down and something to humble their attitude towards life and the life of other creatures. Yes I understand and apreciate the argument that hunting will give the animal a quicker more humane death then in the wild.

Fair enough, I get what your saying.. I also don't like to watch an animal die and I get zero satisifcation from killing any animal. It is part of hunting though.. It's a part of eating in general.. Someone has to kill the animal..

I feel good about getting my meat from nature.. Given a choice of being born as a farm animal like a cow or born as a deer, I've choose to be born as a deer.. At least they get a very good chance at a long life without being killed by a person.. This is why I'm ok with purposely trying to shoot big males when I hunt. Big males have lived their life and rempving them doesn't really affect the reminaing population.

This could be such a long conversation, but I'll stop there..


FYI, if you only have a firearms ban you can bow hunt!
 
Yeah, every hunter i know has a great love and respect for animals and the outdoors. Hunting your food is far more ethical than eating an animal that was raised for slaughter in factory-farm conditions.

Besides, shooting an animal is dealing them a kinder death than what they would otherwise face in nature. Prey animals don't reach a ripe old age then lay down and die peacefully. No, they get old and slow, and ultimately get eaten alive, asshole-first, by a pack of hungry wolves!

100%... If I was a deer, God shot me dead before I die of starvation, disease or getting eaten alive!
 
do the people walking into grocery stores , with the mistreated garbage fed animals have more love for animals? They're just keeping the cycle going...

We have such a disconnect to what really matters in life now... Not just where our food comes from, but we are just disconnected to everything that matters now...
 
Might shock some people, but I did go through a phase where I thought all hunting should be banned and no one except authority should own a gun.. Guessing I was age 16 to 24 years old..

EDIT: My young ignorant self back than probably ate more meat than a family of 6 :ROFLMAO:
 
I think i just said it poorly. I dont like watching animals die. I've killed plenty in my life and feel no need putting myself through that for sport. I did say I would hunt moose and probably deer just because id love to fill my freezer with good healthy meat but I dont have any drive to hunt for passion. The same with farming I would have my own cattle but I cant detach myself from them enough to raise them and slaughter them. I may just be soft in this sense or have just been traumatized slightly from seeing animals die. Ive worked in a slaughterhouse before and seen some other pretty horrible things. So much so that i have nightmares about slaughthouses so it must have effected me. I dont have anything against hunting and I also had a criminal record and fire arms prohibition for most of my life so hunters also never been an opinion for me. What pisses me off is these guys who just get hammered and go out blowing away anything that moves or these goofs you see killing animals for fun. I know some guys who if their dog breaks a leg rather then go to the vet they just put one in the back of its head and if you ask me these guys need a good beat down and something to humble their attitude towards life and the life of other creatures. Yes I understand and apreciate the argument that hunting will give the animal a quicker more humane death then in the wild.

quoting you again because I was thinking about this thread while driving to the gym and thought I'd share with you one of my experiences with another "hunter"

I took a fellow and his son hunting for the first time a few years ago.. I got them into deer hunting fairly easily as I took them out their first year and they both got bucks. I skinned them while they held the legs.. I butchered them up at my house by myself and passed along half the meat to them.. they told me they really only wanted 1 deer worth of meat, but I love deer meat so I agreed to take half of the total if they both shot a buck. During this process I thought I was teaching them how to hunt, skin etc..

Long story short, this family turned out to really only want to do the aspect of hunting where someone takes them hunting, they shoot the deer and then walk away once the animal is dead.. And they did not want any of the meat except the backstraps and some of the bigger hind quatre meat to make jerky.. If you know anything about butchering, they literally wanted the 2 best cuts of the deer and didn't want any of the other stuff.. And as mentioned, they didn't want to be a part of the process of the gut/skin/butcher.. After about 2 or 3 years of this, I ended this hunting relationship.. If you're going to kill an edible animal, you better be eating that animal..

It also irritates me that so many guys will shoot a deer, throw it in the freezer and then give it to their dogs, leave it in the freezer until next deer season and toss it because its freezer burnt or try to give it away..
 
quoting you again because I was thinking about this thread while driving to the gym and thought I'd share with you one of my experiences with another "hunter"

I took a fellow and his son hunting for the first time a few years ago.. I got them into deer hunting fairly easily as I took them out their first year and they both got bucks. I skinned them while they held the legs.. I butchered them up at my house by myself and passed along half the meat to them.. they told me they really only wanted 1 deer worth of meat, but I love deer meat so I agreed to take half of the total if they both shot a buck. During this process I thought I was teaching them how to hunt, skin etc..

Long story short, this family turned out to really only want to do the aspect of hunting where someone takes them hunting, they shoot the deer and then walk away once the animal is dead.. And they did not want any of the meat except the backstraps and some of the bigger hind quatre meat to make jerky.. If you know anything about butchering, they literally wanted the 2 best cuts of the deer and didn't want any of the other stuff.. And as mentioned, they didn't want to be a part of the process of the gut/skin/butcher.. After about 2 or 3 years of this, I ended this hunting relationship.. If you're going to kill an edible animal, you better be eating that animal..

It also irritates me that so many guys will shoot a deer, throw it in the freezer and then give it to their dogs, leave it in the freezer until next deer season and toss it because its freezer burnt or try to give it away..
There's a lot of hunters like that in my area. We find partial wasted carcuses a lot. Whether they are poaching or just want specific parts its disgusting.
 
quoting you again because I was thinking about this thread while driving to the gym and thought I'd share with you one of my experiences with another "hunter"

I took a fellow and his son hunting for the first time a few years ago.. I got them into deer hunting fairly easily as I took them out their first year and they both got bucks. I skinned them while they held the legs.. I butchered them up at my house by myself and passed along half the meat to them.. they told me they really only wanted 1 deer worth of meat, but I love deer meat so I agreed to take half of the total if they both shot a buck. During this process I thought I was teaching them how to hunt, skin etc..

Long story short, this family turned out to really only want to do the aspect of hunting where someone takes them hunting, they shoot the deer and then walk away once the animal is dead.. And they did not want any of the meat except the backstraps and some of the bigger hind quatre meat to make jerky.. If you know anything about butchering, they literally wanted the 2 best cuts of the deer and didn't want any of the other stuff.. And as mentioned, they didn't want to be a part of the process of the gut/skin/butcher.. After about 2 or 3 years of this, I ended this hunting relationship.. If you're going to kill an edible animal, you better be eating that animal..

It also irritates me that so many guys will shoot a deer, throw it in the freezer and then give it to their dogs, leave it in the freezer until next deer season and toss it because its freezer burnt or try to give it away..
Had lots of guys in Edmonton that would get me to pack it into 1lb packs of ground (the whole thing) and they gave it to the food bank. They loved to hunt but didn't want all the meat.
 
Had lots of guys in Edmonton that would get me to pack it into 1lb packs of ground (the whole thing) and they gave it to the food bank. They loved to hunt but didn't want all the meat.

I get donating it to the homeless, but I don't know if that justifies killing something... Im on the fence with this one... If they took some meat and donated a portion then maybe? But I'm guessing lots of these guys donated most if not all..

I would guess this is mostly, if not all, deer?

Many people don't like eating deer meat.. Cool... learn to process it better, learn cook it better or find an animal you like eating would be my suggestion.
 
Fair enough, I get what your saying.. I also don't like to watch an animal die and I get zero satisifcation from killing any animal. It is part of hunting though.. It's a part of eating in general.. Someone has to kill the animal..

I feel good about getting my meat from nature.. Given a choice of being born as a farm animal like a cow or born as a deer, I've choose to be born as a deer.. At least they get a very good chance at a long life without being killed by a person.. This is why I'm ok with purposely trying to shoot big males when I hunt. Big males have lived their life and rempving them doesn't really affect the reminaing population.

This could be such a long conversation, but I'll stop there..


FYI, if you only have a firearms ban you can bow hunt!
"Given a choice of being born as a farm animal like a cow or born as a deer, I've choose to be born as a deer" 👍

And even then, the vast majority of domesticated animals will try to escape at any opportunity.
Not many wild animals try to go the other way.

Makes me think about just how far gone domesticated humans have become.
 
Our mnr, police and road maintenence company's have lists of places to call anytime a moose is hit on our highways. As long as the meat is good it gets donated to different places. Which happens a lot actually, moose are a high risk for drivers and a lot of people are even killed if they are driving small cars.
 
Top