Researchers in Japan use soybean compound to make catfish 100% female - The Mainichi
SHINGU, Wakayama -- A team of researchers in Japan has succeeded in making catfish all female with a compound found in soybeans -- a development that
I read a report last week about the soy/estrogen levels in infant formula. There was the equivalent of 5 birth control pills in one container of formula.
Hanlon's razor is a saying that reads: Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by neglect, ignorance or incompetence. In simpler words: some bad things happen not because of people having bad intentions, but because they did not think it through properly.Well we do that to our children as well. I read a report last week about the soy/estrogen levels in infant formula. There was the equivalent of 5 birth control pills in one container of formula. Look at young people today. Male testosterone levels dropped 50% in 50 years. It’s all being done intentionally. Male masculinity is like cancer to the radical left. I could go on and on….
Hanlon's razor is a saying that reads: Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by neglect, ignorance or incompetence. In simpler words: some bad things happen not because of people having bad intentions, but because they did not think it through properly.
As a species we've been cultivating soybeans for food for more than three thousand years, they're tasty and pretty calorie dense. They grow fast and are easy to cultivate. We just didn't know about the existence and effects of endocrine disruptors until very very recently. There are TONS of supplements, medicines and foods that aren't entirely good for you that we ate for a LONG time before we figured out "Oh Shit, that's not good!"
And that's only the beginning of the problem, are we going to immediately stop growing soybeans and let hundreds of millions of people starve while we spend ten or twenty years breeding a new type of soybean that doesn't have that effect?
Sometimes the "solution" is pretty fucking bad too. When we banned CFC"s because they were fucking with the ozone layer before we had a suitable replacement, millions of poor people in Africa died because they couldn't get access to affordable refrigeration for medicine and food. And it wasn't an emergency. The ozone layer constantly replenishes itself, ozone is an unstable molecule, it has to constantly replenish itself or the ozone layer couldn't exist. Scientists warned people, but tree-hugging had become a religion, so rich white people got expensive refrigerators and poor black people got fucked. That's politics. Then five years later or so, we came up with a good cheap replacement. Can't bring back all those dead black babies though.
I'm sure there are tons of supplements, medicines and foods that we think are wonderful today, that in fifty years we're going to find out aren't so perfect after all.
That's science, it takes time, and data, and a large sample size, and someone actually studying the data, and then replication of results, then further study, etc, etc. Human progress is like pushing a boulder up a hill. It's slow and difficult work.
Still, I think our failures are more easily explained by stupid than evil.
Tried to find it but didn’t. But while looking I found a ton of information about the negative affects. Just a simple google search. Common sense would say breast is best.Do you remember who published this? I'd be interested to read it if you can post a link.
This is just one finding from a quick search:Do you remember who published this? I'd be interested to read it if you can post a link.
This is just one finding from a quick search:
The daily exposure of infants to isoflavones in soy infant-formulas is 6–11 fold higher on a bodyweight basis than the dose that has hormonal effects in adults consuming soy foods. Circulating concentrations of isoflavones in the seven infants fed soy-based formula were 13 000–22 000 times higher than plasma oestradiol concentrations in early life, and may be sufficient to exert biological effects, whereas the contribution of isoflavones from breast-milk and cow-milk is negligible.
Like aguyfrom... I also have some issues with the conclusion here, If the conclusion is that the science is concrete, and soy is poison, and the people who sell it are evil.
When I read the article at the top, it said the experimenter used a SIMILAR chemical to isoflavones called "genistein" not soy, to stimulate the gender change. It said, the experimenter HOPES someday to get more catfish that are female to market, because catfish MIGHT be sensitive to isoflavones.
Also, it's not that hard to change fish or amphibian's gender, it's a natural ability they already have. Some fish just change gender if you move them into a tank with no other fish of the opposite sex for several weeks.
Now I don't do alot of research on soy, I don't much care for tofu or soy milk, and now I'm low carb, so I just don't eat it anyway. BUT, because of this thread I did do a quick search, and apparently, humans may be sensitive to isoflavones, and the overall effect might be good or bad, we don't know.
Notably people who consume alot of food with isoflavones get less cancer in general, and though they initially thought isoflavones would worsen breast cancer in women, because estrogen makes breast cancer worse, when they did the study, they found the opposite effect. So in theory isoflavones mimic estrogen, in vivo, isoflavones might be antiestrogenic.
![]()
The Health Benefits of Isoflavones
Learn about the benefits and risks of taking isoflavones for menopausal symptoms, lowering the risk of cancer and osteoporosis, and cardiovascular health.www.verywellhealth.com
In general I don't think it's a good idea to read science literature when you have an axe to grind.
Isoflavones might be negative or positive for human health, the data is weak and unclear according to Harvard.
https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/soy/
And that makes sense to me, because billions of Asians have been eating the stuff for thousands of years. If it was clearly a problem we would have known by now. If it is bad for us it must be weakly bad, because there's more Japanese centenarians per capita than anywhere else and they eat soybeans like it's the law.
It doesn't affect me though, because I only eat soy a few times a year. Miso soup can be fantastic though and if you ever go to a sushi restaurant I recommend trying it.
Stupid is a component. Humans invent shit without thinking of consequences all the time. We tend to chase bunnies off of cliffs a lot. We get so focused on one accomplishment we’re blind to the fact we’re running out of ground. Look at all the mesothelioma commercials and shit.Hanlon's razor is a saying that reads: Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by neglect, ignorance or incompetence. In simpler words: some bad things happen not because of people having bad intentions, but because they did not think it through properly.
As a species we've been cultivating soybeans for food for more than three thousand years, they're tasty and pretty calorie dense. They grow fast and are easy to cultivate. We just didn't know about the existence and effects of endocrine disruptors until very very recently. There are TONS of supplements, medicines and foods that aren't entirely good for you that we ate for a LONG time before we figured out "Oh Shit, that's not good!"
And that's only the beginning of the problem, are we going to immediately stop growing soybeans and let hundreds of millions of people starve while we spend ten or twenty years breeding a new type of soybean that doesn't have that effect?
Sometimes the "solution" is pretty fucking bad too. When we banned CFC"s because they were fucking with the ozone layer before we had a suitable replacement, millions of poor people in Africa died because they couldn't get access to affordable refrigeration for medicine and food. And it wasn't an emergency. The ozone layer constantly replenishes itself, ozone is an unstable molecule, it has to constantly replenish itself or the ozone layer couldn't exist. Scientists warned people, but tree-hugging had become a religion, so rich white people got expensive refrigerators and poor black people got fucked. That's politics. Then five years later or so, we came up with a good cheap replacement. Can't bring back all those dead black babies though.
I'm sure there are tons of supplements, medicines and foods that we think are wonderful today, that in fifty years we're going to find out aren't so perfect after all.
That's science, it takes time, and data, and a large sample size, and someone actually studying the data, and then replication of results, then further study, etc, etc. Human progress is like pushing a boulder up a hill. It's slow and difficult work.
Still, I think our failures are more easily explained by stupid than evil.