Is fish oil good for you? Maybe not.

this is true actually, lots of fish oils are junk, some even contain mercury, supplement industry isn't regulated by the FDA so you'll only find out after the fact
i only use kirkland

i only take 1 capsule every few days, high epa/dha, essential fatty acids because i dont get it from my diet
Im willing to bet the script omega 3s are made by some of the same producers as the ones on the shelf at a supplement store. Still there are varying degrees of quality and like most things in life, you get what you pay for.

I also use the kirkland Atlantic salmon fishoils(2 capsules per day). The best test i have for quality is if its crap, ill burp it up and taste it, if its good i wont even know i took it. We couldn't possibly know unless we took a bunch and got a lab to analyze them.

FDA approval doesn't mean much these days IMO and we're also in Canda where our regulations go through health canada anyways which also doesnt mean much these days lol. The pandemic was the straw that broke the camels back for me.
 
yes it thins the blood so you can bleed to death, they also typically ask you to stop taking all vitamins/supplements regardless as well incase theres any contradictions with drugs they need to use
I have surgery in early December.. like the first week.. my pre surgery appointment is 7 days before my surgery...

Never had surgery before... maybe I should contact them and ask..
 
I have surgery in early December.. like the first week.. my pre surgery appointment is 7 days before my surgery...

Never had surgery before... maybe I should contact them and ask..
You can lower your dose, at 4 caps per day regular strength 180/120 dha/epa or the other way around your fine.
If I go at 6 or more, and get a nose bleeding is take a long time to stop the bleeding.
 
You can lower your dose, at 4 caps per day regular strength 180/120 dha/epa or the other way around your fine.
If I go at 6 or more, and get a nose bleeding is take a long time to stop the bleeding.
Thats what I do so I dont have to donate blood as much. Just let my nose bleed ..lol
 
I have surgery in early December.. like the first week.. my pre surgery appointment is 7 days before my surgery...

Never had surgery before... maybe I should contact them and ask..
I'm guessing then the they didn't give you a sheet of instructions about pre and post protocols. I think that is standard so you'll probably get something at your appt. I'm sure every situation is different, I don't recall ever being asked for more than a few days.
 
I didn't get through the entire vid - sorry, don't believe half of what I hear. I have heard this before with most oils and other products. Oxidation, free radicals, antioxidants, etc. Is EVOO and fish oil susceptible to oxygenation - sure but not if you keep it in a room temp or fridge and away from light. The only double blind placebo of dozens I read on fish oil that was negative indicated it exacerbated fatty liver but it was a small group albeit the controls were good. That was what I found - 1 article and who knows if it 100% accurate.
I probably posted it years ago. Otherwise, fish oil IMO is one of the best supplements for getting your BP down quickly, helping protect your kidneys with a host of health benefits. Should you believe me - no, go research yourself and make make a decision.
Is there bad fish oil from companies that find the cheapest method of making fish oil and is the same quality as a company like Carleson's (I mention that name because I read a lot on the company, their standards, and believe their fish oil is top notch). There are not the same controls in supplements as medications that are prescribed so do your research and its good to question everything.
I applaud anyone who has a counter argument on a supplement or medication with scientific data to make us think and question. How many times, if you live long enough, is something good for you today, and then 10 years later it may still be good for you but only up to a certain dosage or found to have bad side effects. This will ever be such - we don't know today how something new will impact us in 10-20 years so we become guinea pigs but luckily there are a lot of smart members here who do a lot of research.
 
this is true actually, lots of fish oils are junk, some even contain mercury, supplement industry isn't regulated by the FDA so you'll only find out after the fact
i only use kirkland

i only take 1 capsule every few days, high epa/dha, essential fatty acids because i dont get it from my diet
This is why you want fish oil from small fish like sardines or anchovies, yhe bigger the fish the more the mercury.
 
I have surgery in early December.. like the first week.. my pre surgery appointment is 7 days before my surgery...

Never had surgery before... maybe I should contact them and ask..
they'll definitely bring it up in your pre-surgery appointment to list every single medication/supplement/vitamin you're taking and most likely tell you to stop taking anything that isn't vital. If its open surgery they do blood work to test your blood clotting factors to make sure you're not at risk, blood type for transfusions ready

fish oils was one of the main things they brought up when i had my surgeries, i stopped everything 2 weeks ahead to be safe, no point risking anything during a surgery where they practically have you on life support for a few hours
 
I gave up taking fish oil 7 years ago after reading the research on it. Specifically the work of Kummerow, (the guy who brought the scrutiny on trans fats.)

Like most things, when asking is something beneficial, ask " compared to what?"
If you have a high linoleic acid diet? I'd say for sure it is.

If taking it for better lipid values, omega 6 vegetable oils also reduce LDL cholesterol numbers, but who supplements with Mazola and Canola oil?
Look into how those intervention studies went. I personally doubt an even less saturated fat would fare better (and probably worse mechanistically.)

It's a complex systems analysis, therefore almost impossible to reduce to a simple good/bad outcome.
My personal go to heuristic for questions like this is the evolutionary lens, where maybe bleeding out due to injury (or surgery) wouldn't be the smartest of adaptations.

Of course, we no longer live in the pristine stone age, so perhaps there is (if not benefit), lesser detriment to taking it than not taking it in todays environment.
As always, experience will determine where one personally falls on the bell curve.
 
I gave up taking fish oil 7 years ago after reading the research on it. Specifically the work of Kummerow, (the guy who brought the scrutiny on trans fats.)

Like most things, when asking is something beneficial, ask " compared to what?"
If you have a high linoleic acid diet? I'd say for sure it is.

If taking it for better lipid values, omega 6 vegetable oils also reduce LDL cholesterol numbers, but who supplements with Mazola and Canola oil?
Look into how those intervention studies went. I personally doubt an even less saturated fat would fare better (and probably worse mechanistically.)

It's a complex systems analysis, therefore almost impossible to reduce to a simple good/bad outcome.
My personal go to heuristic for questions like this is the evolutionary lens, where maybe bleeding out due to injury (or surgery) wouldn't be the smartest of adaptations.

Of course, we no longer live in the pristine stone age, so perhaps there is (if not benefit), lesser detriment to taking it than not taking it in todays environment.
As always, experience will determine where one personally falls on the bell curve.
Excellent point sir, would have this whole subject would have made a good entry in the "Yeah but ..." thread along with the question of "are seed oils bad" . None of this is black and white, not much is I guess.
 
Top