Honestly we couldn’t feed the world likely without gene splicing.
And carrageen is literally dried seaweed. 30 years ago we would put it into cheap hams to hold water.
Wheat gluten creates an inflamitory responce as well, lol. Well most simple carbs do.
Actually we could likely pick apart every single food item and show a downside.
I don’t worry about it too much. But my products at work are made as clean as possible and I eat at from work 95% of the time.
My worst offender is sodium phosphate and sodium nitrates in sausages (dry cured or smoked). We are very regulated with nitrate levels, unlike about 20 years ago we could add what we wanted. There was a diminishing return. Same with phosphates, they are pretty expensive so we only use what is needed. Phosphates have likely been used for 70+ years, more in europe than here. Nitrates likely thousands of years.
Cool fact about nitrates, by the time you eat the sausage about 70% of it has disapated. We actually add vit C to stablize the nitrates so they don’t degrade as fast. UV radation (sunlight) degrades nitrates quickly. That is why sometimes when you look at the cold cuts at the grocery store, the front of the piece looks grey instead of pink.
I agree that how we've done things, we now require GMO crops to maintain and grow global population. However it's the cart before the horse. Every species has a natural limit based on resources available in its ecosystem (carrying capacity). It's the availability of more resources that drives population growth.
Good example is the increased rate of population growth that occurred post WW2. It was driven by the introduction of Haber-Bosch synthetic fertilizer process. Without it, world population is estimated to have been at around 4B today. Over 3B people alive today owe their nutrition and existence to synthetic fertilizer use.
If one believes constant and continuous population growth is a good thing, and our economic systems rely on it continuing, then there could be a case for the need for even more GMOs
There are also environmental arguments, such as making plants create their own pesticides so we don't need to spray pesticides. Or growing beans with complete proteins to eliminate beef to fight climate change. But IMO when you look into these technologies, they are really all about increasing control of the product for the company. ie the bottom line. Look at the capture of the corn industry in USA for example.
But anyway, this was about the possibility they may be unsafe for consumption. Or rather, less safe than sugar.
I personally don't believe there is much potential for harm from most of the existing ones.
Even some cross kingdom ones, like crossing beef with tomato, I can't see an obvious problem.
If you look at what DNA does, all it does is hold sequence patterns for creation of various proteins. There are trillions of potential combinations, and we have no idea what the effects of most of them are. We rely on our billions of years of exposure to various proteins to allow us to handle ones we've evolved with, but there are numerous examples of ones that can cause damage in the long term, and even near instant death.
In a product like a tomato that produces myoglobin, we have been exposed to those proteins for a long time, so they're not novel to our systems. It's in the more esoteric genes from bacteria, fungus etc. That humans have not been evolutionarily exposed to in quantity before, where I see a potential for harm.
Yes they are tested, yet testing is not robust enough IMO, and they do almost no transgenerational testing. Epigenome changes can take 3 or 4 generations to appear and remember it's proteins that act as signaling molecules to drive those changes. We're literally gambling with our grandchildrens health.
In another thread there is a discussion of peptides, which are just short proteins.
What are the long term effects of taking BPC157, or any other peptides? Would you feed random peptides to your kids? People are rationally wary of isolated things like those, but consider we could be consuming thousands of novel peptides in GMO foods, both directly or as protein fragments.
For the same reasons as above, nitrates in reasonable doses hold zero concerns for me. Hell we make them in our saliva.
As for carrageenan, there are lots of examples of things we've used for decades before figuring out they're maybe not a good idea. And the fact it's seaweed doesn't make it safe, likely 90% or more of plants are toxic to humans. Seaweeds are generally safer than most though.
If one can eat it without I'll effects, enjoy. But I think people should have the right to know of the proven
causal cancer link with poligeenan. And I certainly think carrageenan is far riskier than sugar. It's a no brainier for me to avoid it because it gives me the shits.
You mention another one there too. Smoked meats. We know smoke is carcinogenic in the lungs, why wouldn't it be in the gastrointestinal tract? Perhaps cured meats getting a bad rap all this time is actually from the smoke?
Even if they proved it was, I'd still eat pounds of it a week because it's fucking awesome.
Long rant, interesting stuff to me