Collagen vs.

Goldenrod

Well-known member
Staff member
Morning,

The idea of collagen formation makes sense to me to help with degenerative joint issues as we get older. As far as skin, etc. the same applies.
Coming out of the mouths of two specialists (doctors) - they claim your body can not absorb collagen supplements and you are only getting a fraction of what is advertised.
I know @Sorbate is a believer and I'm interested in other's opinions as well.
I listened to a few people, read some articles such as: https://www.news-medical.net/health/Collagen-Synthesis.aspx - and many people/so called experts say you are wasting your time taking collagen supplements. If you want more collagen take L-Lysine, Proline, and arginine. There are some side effects for some to arginine so read up if you intend to try it. As a bonus it is known as a natural remedy for ED and is sold as a '24 hr pump' product.
As for Lysine - this is just one page but: https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/lysine-benefits

Note it claims to block arginine to help cold sores. All the same most people I have listened to who have sore joints and want to supplement outside chondroiten, MSM, and glucosamine, often mention these three supplements. There are only so many supplements a person is going to want to take and money can be an issue but curious on other's opinion. Considering I have sore joints and the Glu/chon/MSM does help if taken long enough, and I don't like bad pain I am considering giving this a 3 month trial. The supplements are not expensive.
Just info to consider.
GR
 
I have read/listened to the same. One Dr drew a comparison by saying "if you eat hair, it won't make you grow a better head of hair". Maybe do some research on bone broth. I use a brand called Great Lakes off of amazon but there are a lot of good brands out there.
We could also say, if you eat muscle tissue, it won’t make your muscles bigger, lol.
Being sarcastic btw
 
From what I remember there is scant little scientific evidence that shows even a minor benefit to supplementing it. I recall some small benefits for skin in a study or two but they had suspect funding, ie they were selling it. Can't remember anything indicating it's of benefit to any of the joint tissues. I heard something about another recent study, if I can find it I will post it.
 
From what I remember there is scant little scientific evidence that shows even a minor benefit to supplementing it. I recall some small benefits for skin in a study or two but they had suspect funding, ie they were selling it. Can't remember anything indicating it's of benefit to any of the joint tissues. I heard something about another recent study, if I can find it I will post it.
No so much collagen specifically, but my thought is if we don’t eat some of the building blocks needed to repair joints, where are they getting the raw material from? Do we synthesize put of basic protiens?
 
If eating collagen is a waste then how do people get it outside of supplements? Before supps we got it from bone broth and skin. So I have my doubts it's accurate

Also ever since my parkour days, jumping from high ass places and climbing buildings, and a few brawls, I've always had knee pain. To the point I would even limp during cold whether. I no longer have that pain and the only thing I've done differently is take 7.5 grams of collagen daily. I took it for skin, I haven't noticed a whole lot there. But I guess when it comes to aging there is no reversing it only stopping or slowing it down so idk.
 
The hair argument is inept. Your hair is made mostly of dead cells. Your hair is just a collection of dead cells once it's visible.... So maybe if you ate a bunch of hair follicles you might grow hair but I doubt there's a study done on that lol and you would have to pluck every hair on your head to get a teaspoon of the lil root bulb thingies
 
@Palmer1991 too
No so much collagen specifically, but my thought is if we don’t eat some of the building blocks needed to repair joints, where are they getting the raw material from? Do we synthesize put of basic protiens?
You got it. Collagen is made up of amino acids. Collagen itself is a poor source of amino acids and on top of that is very poorly digested. If you ingest collagen with the goal of increasing collagen synthesis you are taking the long way around and using a terrible inefficient base material. It needs to be "digested" down to peptide level first then to amino acids then the tiny little amount of amino's present need to be reassemble (synthesized) back into collagen.
If you really feel like you need to use it a pre hydrolyzed version would be your best bet as its already partially digested.
But why? IMO the better solution is a good diet. Good for this purpose means lots of complete protein and making sure you have the bases covered for the things that support the digestion of that protein and synthesis of collagen specifically, things like Vit C, Zinc ang Mag come to mind but you'd have to look it up for a proper and complete list.

Positive anecdotal reports are plentiful. Unfortunately they are subject to issues involving lack of controls and placebo effects though.

I've only pointed at the science in this thread but I'm not dismissing anyone's anecdotes or experiences, if you believe it helps you go right ahead. Myself I think it's a complete waste of cash and energy because anyone living a bodybuilding lifestyle should already be practicing the strategy I listed above.

Here is the study I mentioned previously. Best one I've ever seen on the subject. There is certainly some room for arguement with regard to specific circumstances and questions but they are small and defeatable when logic is applied IMO.

 
I think it's still being debated whether or not the actual molecules of collagen get absorbed or if it is just broken down into amino acids

i would assume just from thinking about people I know with joint issues that it isn't the collagen in the diet which will help with joints, but rather hormones and health of the individual
 
The hair argument is inept. Your hair is made mostly of dead cells. Your hair is just a collection of dead cells once it's visible.... So maybe if you ate a bunch of hair follicles you might grow hair but I doubt there's a study done on that lol and you would have to pluck every hair on your head to get a teaspoon of the lil root bulb thingies
Palmer - he was stating eating hair is not going to cause your hair to grow. @aGuyFromWinnipeg was stating the fact that you can't eat hair to grow hair. It is appears you are stating he is wrong albeit you are actually agreeing with him. Maybe I am misunderstanding your point with the use of terminology like 'inept' and 'lil root bulb thingies' but I am confident you are stating the same fact. No one would do this. I also don't think eating hair follicles will make you grow hair but I never contemplated it before.
@gondar1 explains it well above and he has forgot more than most know.
I read Sorbate's comments in the past as he is a butcher and has stated a lot of the parts of meat/animal we don't eat, we should because it provides the building blocks for collagen.
If taking collagen supplements have helped you, keep doing it. My inquiry/question was based on reading multiple articles/talking to docs stating collagen supplements are not bio available but the 3 amino acids are and will help form collagen. Just asking members if they have an opinion on it.
 
Palmer - he was stating eating hair is not going to cause your hair to grow. @aGuyFromWinnipeg was stating the fact that you can't eat hair to grow hair. It is appears you are stating he is wrong albeit you are actually agreeing with him. Maybe I am misunderstanding your point with the use of terminology like 'inept' and 'lil root bulb thingies' but I am confident you are stating the same fact. No one would do this. I also don't think eating hair follicles will make you grow hair but I never contemplated it before.
@gondar1 explains it well above and he has forgot more than most know.
I read Sorbate's comments in the past as he is a butcher and has stated a lot of the parts of meat/animal we don't eat, we should because it provides the building blocks for collagen.
If taking collagen supplements have helped you, keep doing it. My inquiry/question was based on reading multiple articles/talking to docs stating collagen supplements are not bio available but the 3 amino acids are and will help form collagen. Just asking members if they have an opinion on it.

lol... I think it was just an improvised comment. Stating you're not going to improve collagen production in the skin by eating collagen same as you won't improve hair growth by eating hair. I didn't take it as science, but perhaps makes some sense. I wouldn't say taking collagen is bad, it does contain amino acids and protein. (although not a complete protein). I just think it's overpriced, overprocessed and overrated.

If we are doing Collagen vs. Bone Broth, I think bone broth has more benefits and does contain unprocessed collagen. So perhaps the best of both worlds.

I posted earlier about Great Lakes, The company looks completely different now and I can't even find a bone broth in their product list. It's all collagen! Makes me wonder if they were bought out.
 
Sugar free jello is the cheapest way to get in your collagen. Or you can eat head cheese, lol, blood and tongue loaf.

I still prefer getting it the natural way, thru fatty meats like chuck, and eating the skin of chickens and thighs. I think collagen only is likely a waste of time. There is likely other things missing vs if you drank bone broth.
 
Sugar free jello is the cheapest way to get in your collagen. Or you can eat head cheese, lol, blood and tongue loaf.

I still prefer getting it the natural way, thru fatty meats like chuck, and eating the skin of chickens and thighs. I think collagen only is likely a waste of time. There is likely other things missing vs if you drank bone broth.
seriously? jello?
 
Fair, but this is the ingredients in sugar free jello.

Gelatin, Adipic Acid, Disodium Phosphate, Maltodextrin, Fumaric Acid, Aspartame (Phenylketonurics: Contains Phenylalanine), (Sweetener), Contains Less than 2% of Natural and Artificial Flavor, Acesulfame Potassium (Sweetener), Salt, Yellow 6, Red 40, BHA (Preservative).

Can't imagine adding this to a daily diet.

Unless you're referring to something else.
 
Top